ALL TALK, NO PROOF – MINISTER MUST RELEASE MYSTERY REPORT ON SO-CALLED ILLICIT TOBACCO NUMBERS

The Australian Association of Convenience Stores (AACS) has questioned the Albanese Government’s claim that the illicit tobacco market is shrinking, after the Illicit Tobacco and E-cigarette Commissioner (ITEC) made the claim with no report or data to prove it.

AACS CEO Theo Foukkare said the public should rightly question claims that are not backed up with evidence.

“The ITEC claims the illicit tobacco black market fell from 5,972 to 5,893 tonnes. That’s a drop of 79 tonnes – which is just 1.3 per cent.

“That’s hardly a number to be celebrated – if it is, in fact, even correct.

“We want to know where ITEC pulled that number from – the so-called 5,893 tonnes – because legal tobacco sales were just 3,975 tonnes last financial year. That puts illicit tobacco at around 60 per cent of the market based on ITEC’s numbers. But then we have the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) which says four in five nicotine products consumed in Australia are now illegal.

“If the ABS is right, the black market could be two to three times bigger than the Albanese Government and ITEC are claiming.

“New illicit tobacco shops are popping up everywhere, online websites are moving massive volumes, and organised crime is getting better at evading law enforcement through encrypted messaging platforms and direct deliveries. It’s embarrassing for the government to be doing victory laps over this alleged 1.3 per cent drop in black market illicit tobacco,” AACS CEO Theo Foukkare said.

Mr Foukkare said AACS’s 80,000 member employees want real answers.

“Where is the report to back this up? What data is behind this number? What is happening state by state? Where are online sales captured? And how can the Federal Government’s own agencies hold such differing data and positions on the size of this deadly problem?”

Mr Foukkare said ITEC’s use of the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) smoking data made the estimate even harder to trust. The Federal Government claims daily smoking is at a record low of 5.8 per cent. Wesfarmers Health data from more than 320,000 Australians puts it at 11.2 per cent – that is insane, it’s almost double. NSW Health has 11 per cent of adults smoking, and WA Health reports smoking rates increased from 10 to 12 per cent – the first increase in 30 years.

“AIHW’s data is half of what the other reputable measures are showing. So of course, it serves ITEC to estimate its rates on the lowest smoking figure going around to get the lowest answer. That’s not evidence, it’s a game of ‘pick the numbers that best make the story look good’,” Mr Foukkare said.

AACS commends state and territory governments for their dedication to shutting down around 1,400 illegal shopfronts and thanks the Commonwealth for continuing to treat illicit tobacco as a national crisis, including through the National Disruption Group.

“Credit where it’s due. The states have rolled up their sleeves, and it is a positive step. We are starting to see some positive impact in Queensland, but we’re not seeing it anywhere else yet. The Commonwealth setting up of the National Disruption Group was the right call, and the Australian Border Force and police are doing a great job on the ground,” Mr Foukkare said.

“However, enforcement alone won’t fix this deadly crisis. Illicit consumption went from 12 per cent to 80 per cent at the same time enforcement ramped up. And when a pack of legal, government-regulated smokes costs so much more than the dodgy products the criminals sell them for – the crooks win, and legitimate retailers keep losing.

“The only real fix is to reduce excise, and to legally regulate the sale of strictly made to government code vapes and nicotine pouches through licensed retailers,” Mr Foukkare said.

“Government, it’s time to change position. Treasurer Jim Chalmers should use the upcoming MYEFO to do it: cut excise, regulate vapes and nicotine pouches, and claw back the billions in revenue currently being handed to organised crime,” Mr Foukkare said.

AACS 5 Point Plan

  1. Cut tobacco excise by 80%.
  2. A regulated retail market for vapes and nicotine products, not pharmacy only.
  3. One national legislative framework.
  4. A single Commonwealth-funded enforcement body, delivered by the states.
  5. Shut down online direct-to-consumer sites delivering via Australia Post.

Media enquiries:

Theo Foukkare is available for interview on 0423 003 133.

Posted in

Subscribe to our free mailing list and always be the first to receive the latest news and updates.