THE JUDGES’ VERDICT: WHERE FOODVENIENCE IS HEADING

The shortlist for Best Foodvenience Store in the World 2026 is live and the industry vote is open. We asked our judges what this year’s 24 entries told them about convenience retail, and where it goes next.

Their answers, from across the world, agree on one point above all: food is no longer something convenience stores add on. Increasingly, it is the reason customers visit.

Dan Munford, CEO of Insight Research & Global Convenience, says the competition’s value lies in its openness. Every entrant answers the same questions, often with real trading figures, creating “a shared evidence base that no single operator could assemble alone.”

Harry Milloff, CEO of knowledge partner The Moseley Group, sees the timing as significant. “The c-store industry is evolving in real time as foodservice moves from an adjacent offering to a central part of the guest experience and business model,” he says. “This competition captures that transformation at exactly the right moment.”

A global benchmark, built in public

Judges Christian Warning & Harry Milloff

For Theo Foukkare, CEO of the Australian Association of Convenience Stores (AACS), the case for the competition is simple. “Food is now the growth engine of convenience, and this competition is the best global benchmark we have for what great looks like,” he says. “For me, the learning is the real value.”

Giselle Valdevez, co-founder and executive director of Valsa, judging for the third time, describes the role as looking at the industry through a “friendly magnifying glass”. The competition, she says, “celebrates the best of what we do and sets a benchmark for the future of retail.”

Joe Heather, Regional General Manager for Northern Europe at Deliverect, wanted to find the outliers. “I think it’s important these examples get recognised and shared with a wider audience. The more retailers can learn from those getting it right, the faster we can move the industry forward.”

Janet Sithole, Head of NFR Africa at Puma Energy, who has led convenience retail growth across 23 African markets, joined the panel to bring “an African perspective to this global conversation”, while Joe Chiovera, who oversees innovation and culinary at Premium Brands Holdings and calls himself a “food guy” with more than 30 years in the c-store channel, says seeing the industry’s “evolution, growth, and the willingness to change makes me extremely proud.”

Food is now the business

Joe Heather sampling the offer at one of our entrants

Joe Chiovera sums up the mood of the panel. “For years the echo throughout the industry was, ‘Foodservice is the future!’ Don’t look now, but the future is here.”

The entries back that up. “Food isn’t a sideline anymore, it’s the business,” says Theo Foukkare. “In many of the entries, food makes up 40 to 70 per cent of shop sales or more. In some cases food and coffee now deliver more gross profit than fuel and retail combined.” Giselle Valdevez agrees that foodservice “is not just another category”, but a driver of store traffic, loyalty and long-term results.

For Joe Heather, the most striking shift is competitive. “Some of these convenience stores are starting to look like the QSRs of the future, but with the added advantage of a retail proposition,” he says. Strategic advisor Tammy Gathright was struck by the sheer range: “We’re talking about places that bring together restaurants, grocery stores, cafés, sports bars and entire communities under one roof.”

Matt Harrison, Operations Director at Asda Express, sees a set of “hygiene factors” emerging in stores that are world class at foodvenience: “great coffee, fresh bakeries, clarity on the missions they are serving, the mix of grocery and hospitality, high-cost labour models and high capital spend.”

Theo Foukkare also notes the balance the best operators strike between their own food and the brands customers already know. “Own brands drive frequency, partner brands drive destination.” For markets like Australia, where legal tobacco sales are collapsing, he sees food as the category that must fill the gap. “One retailer gave up its tobacco backbar for an open kitchen, and another has cut its tobacco dependence while doubling food sales.”

Technology: connecting the pieces

The judges saw technology working mostly behind the scenes. Giselle Valdevez highlights automated inventory, integrated POS, kitchen workflows and loyalty apps that “empowered store teams and accelerated service without replacing human touch.” Theo Foukkare points to AI forecasting to cut waste, alongside kiosks, order ahead, delivery and loyalty, all “making food easier to buy and more profitable to run.”

Joe Chiovera sees loyalty, order ahead and delivery becoming alternative revenue streams “for an ever-changing way of life and demographic”. Janet Sithole is blunter: “Technology is increasingly central to this proposition, this is the time to get on board.”

But Joe Heather warns the job is not finished. “There’s still a gap between having the individual technologies and actually connecting them effectively,” he says. “Bringing those together with food preparation, inventory and store operations is where things get really interesting.”

Destination beats location

Chrissy Blasinsky visiting sites with the NACS team

The strongest entries give customers reasons to come and to stay. “Destination beats location,” says Theo Foukkare, citing seating, play areas, dog parks, trucker lounges and even a sports bar. “Some sites now get customers who don’t need fuel at all.” Joe Chiovera describes the same shift as businesses “meeting the customers where they are going”.

Provenance is a real point of difference. Giselle Valdevez saw “a strong emphasis on regional pride, from locally sourced ingredients and regional chef menus to partnerships with neighborhood coffee roasters.” Theo Foukkare adds: “Tortillas pressed in store, beef from the family farm a few kilometres away, national pastries done properly.”

Giselle Valdevez also singles out social media, where active channels and influencer collaborations are “building an entertaining and relatable digital presence that connects especially with Gen Z.” And with EV charging growing, Theo Foukkare notes that “charging time is eating time”, with dwell time designed into the food offer from day one.

Where foodvenience is heading

Dan Munford & Joe Heather on their foodvenience roadtrip

“The traditional convenience model has flipped,” says Theo Foukkare. “It used to be a fuel stop that sold food. Now it’s becoming a food destination that happens to sell energy solutions.” The competitive set has changed with it, he adds: convenience stores now compete with QSRs, specialty cafés and supermarkets.

Janet Sithole describes the same transformation as a move “beyond the traditional forecourt convenience retail model towards destinations that combine convenience, food, services and complementary retail experiences”, or what she calls “shopping malls with pumps”. For Africa, she says, the opportunity is significant.

Joe Heather expects foodservice and retail to “genuinely operate as one business, rather than two separate propositions under the same roof.” Central to that is the hybrid basket: “A customer should be able to order a freshly prepared meal, add a drink, snacks or a few grocery essentials, and have that fulfilled through one connected experience.” Still, he adds, “the food proposition still needs to be excellent.”

Changing eating habits will shape the offer. Giselle Valdevez points to healthier options, higher protein, bold flavours and “smaller portions (driven by the GLP-1 effect)”. Jen Dodd, CEO of Main Squeeze Juice Co., sees consumers “eating smaller bites, more frequently and expecting enhanced nutrition, especially protein- and fiber-rich choices.” For her, foodvenience “is not simply an ‘added category’; it is an integrated way to serve changing consumer needs and build a stronger, more resilient business.”

Theo Foukkare’s view of the next few years includes more fresh, made-on-site food and dinner-tonight solutions, value and quality together, and smarter use of data and AI. “The operators who commit to food as a core capability, not an add-on, will be the ones still standing and growing in 10 years.”

Here to stay

For Harry Milloff, the learning is far from over. “We all continue to learn on this journey, from one another, from consumers and from the operators pushing the boundaries of what is possible. One thing is for sure: foodvenience is here to stay.”

Matt Harrison puts it more personally: “It makes me really proud of the industry that we work in, as there are some amazing stores in the competition.”

The top 12 shortlisted stores are now in the industry vote, which closes on 5 November. Votes are combined with the judges’ scores, and the winner will be announced on 12 November. Vote now.

The 2026 judging panel: Dan Munford, CEO, Insight Research & Global Convenience; Harry Milloff, CEO, The Moseley Group; Chrissy Blasinsky, Digital & Content Specialist, NACS; Joe Chiovera, Innovation and Culinary, Premium Brands Holdings; Jen Dodd, CEO, Main Squeeze Juice Co.; Theo Foukkare, CEO, Australian Association of Convenience Stores; Tammy Gathright, Principal and Strategic Advisor; Matt Harrison, Operations Director, Asda Express; Joe Heather, General Manager, Northern Europe, Deliverect; Janet Sithole, Head of NFR Africa, Puma Energy; Giselle Valdevez, Co-founder and Executive Director, Valsa; Christian Warning, Managing Director, The Retail Marketeers.

View article source here.

Posted in

Subscribe to our free mailing list and always be the first to receive the latest news and updates.